Hortonville, WI Lake Property For Sale (2 Real Estate Listings)

Sort by:

New

$709,900 Black Otter Lake

↓ $30,000

216 E Main Street, HORTONVILLE

5 Beds 3 Baths 2 Acres 3,882 SqFt Single Family MLS® # 50315602

Exceptional 5 bed, 2.2 bath residence situated on 2.35 acres, offering over 3,800 sq ft of refined living across two levels. The remodeled chef’s kitchen anchors the home with sleek finishes...

Century 21 Ace Realty

New

$399,000 Black Otter Lake

132 E Main Street, HORTONVILLE

0 Acres 2,765 SqFt Commercial MLS® # 50320727

EXCEPTIONAL LOCATION for any Venue situated on Main Street with 130+ Ft of frontage on Otter Lake backdrop PLUS Veterans Village Park next door! FORMALLY a BMO bank branch with 2,765 SQ FT o...

Century 21 Ace Realty

Hortonville, WI Real Estate Statistics

Average Price	$349K
Lowest Price	$54.9K
Highest Price	$1.4M
Total Listings	42
Avg. Price/SQFT	$215

Property Types (active listings)

As of February 11, 2026 there are 2 active Hortonville, WI lake property listings for sale with an average listing price of $554,450. The highest-priced waterfront listing is $709,900, while the lowest priced waterfront listing can be purchased for $399,000. Hortonville, WI lakeshore listings have an average price of $164 per square foot, based on listings with an average of 5.0 bedrooms, 3.0 bathrooms, and 3,324 square feet of living space.